Catfish Annies in Commack

Very tasty/fresh fish. - The reason I gave a two star rating, however, is because the food is overpriced, and the staff were rude to my mother!

Great tasting food.Ordered fried catfish with chips.Fried chicken with baked potato,salad with house dressing

We were excited to try a local seafood restaurant and were sorely disappointed. The seared tuna was awful and my son took one bite of his hamburger and spit it out. The other items we had were barely edible.

Tasty food at good prices in a casual atmosphere.

Had the Swordfish. It's a must have. I will definitely be back 🙂

Food is excellent and always fresh. Tony the owner is a great guy and staff friendly and professional

I bought two lbs of seafood salad when I arrived at home I realized the container was filled with liquid half inch from the top . I was charged $50.00 but there was not a label on the container telling me how much per pound or the weight.The owner waited on me . Does he make the price in his head Also he was not wearing a mask I will never go back .

Food wishes perfectly prepared and delicious. Fish was very fresh, and the restaurant immaculate. No fishy or fried smells what president. Unfortunately, once the main meal was finished, a waiter asked us if we would like some coffee or dessert, to which we said that we would like to take a look at the selection. He walked away, and never came back with the menu or coffee. The waitress who had first taken our order must have gotten busy, because my friend had to chase her down in order to ask for the check. Five stars for the food. Three stars for service

Absolutely great. Good food. Service was great Very good atmosphere. Lot of history within that place

Great food and excellent service. The kitchen was very accommodating to customize a dish due to food allergies.

Freshest seafood in town. This is a hidden gem. Our waitress Tina was beyond amazing and gave us some phenomenal recommendations. Clams casino are to die for , shrimp cocktail was unbelievable, you can't go wrong.

Has good food and friendly service. Clean restaurant. The price is a bit high for many dishes. The quality is ok. But...As a commercial lobster fisherman, I have to say, The lobster is usually over cooked and chewy. They charge a high price for over cooked lobster, and need to cook the lobster a lot less to have a higher quality!

Good Seafood and a friendly staff. I really liked the shrimp over linguine lots of shrimp!

I LOVE going to this place . They make everyone they meet feels like family..

Food was so fresh! Outstanding service!

My mom and I have been having our annual mom daughter seafood dinner here for years. Fresh fish, great value, we can wear pjs and it’s super comfortable and casual. We love it

We absolutely love this place! Food is delicious. Would highly recommend.

I was told about this place from a friend but never got to go thefinally got there. Let me tell u It was great had the shrimp & fish delicious will definitely be going back. Keep up the good work.

Staff and owner are friendly and the fish was very fresh

Good food good service pricey. Food is not cheap here. Bring your wallet.$145 for 3 people

Excellent food and service. Prices very good.

I love this place. It’s comfortable and casual and the food is always delicious! The staff is pleasant, polite and professional.

Great seafood place fresh and fast. Can make it on an hour lunch break!!

Always a good meal, always friendly!

The best place to go for seafood. Consistently fresh seafood and very good staff. Been going for years and will continue to go whenever we crave seafood.

I absolutely love this place !! I have been going for years. The owner is very friendly as is the staff. I always get the chilled seafood salad, it reminds me of how my Dad used to make it. Their shrimp is the best of the best. Everything is super fresh and clean. For lunch i just had the best broiled lemon sole i have ever tasted !! Highly recommend this place to all. Go check them out !!

Had the lobster lunch special and it was great! waitress was good and very nice.

Service polite but slow, was not crowded but took a while to get dinner. 2 Lobster special ordered overcooked. When returned 1 1/2 of total not eaten another dinner scallops was suggested and taken. Drowning in butter.. when bill came, I was charged for the higher priced lobster...Upon requesting a manager, the waiter said he was and that was their policy. Not my fault they overcooked my dinner, why hold me responsible?

Delightful place. Nothing fancy about it, but great food and superior value.

I have eaten here for years, and have always enjoyed the fish & chips. Went today for lunch, arriving at 12:40. We were “greeted” by a man who rudely told us we would be waiting for ten minutes. Our waiter was much nicer, and explained that the restaurant doesn’t open until 1:00 (what?), but upon learning that our unwelcoming greeting was from the owner we decided to find another place to eat. We stopped to tell him we were taking our business elsewhere because of the way he greeted us and he responded, “Go ahead, I don’t care!” That is our last visit to Catfish Annies!

The freshest fish- great prepared food-amazing selection.

Don't eat at seafood restaurant that's no where near a body of water.

GREAT FOOD FRIENDLY STAFF

Great lobsters and fried shrimp dinners. Wife and I shared a 3 pound lobster recently. Cooked perfectly. $5 sharing charge was worth it. We each got a salad, baked potato and Cole slaw. Service was good too. Will go back real soon

I love their raw clams, never had a bad one even in summer

I didn't order anything yet but everything looks so good.

Foods good..... price's BAD... PS... unless its a sure shot... Go Dutch..

Just ate a good meal...only negative was the NE clam chowder was a disappointment,clam nonexistent all potato ,the broiled platter was fresh and seasoned nicely good value for the price will go back again

First time trying lobster. Didn't disappoint. I was flavorful. Waitress was very kind and had awesome recommendation. Helper where friendly. Thanks for the great food.

Amazing Seafood. Closest thing tio City Island food. Definitely recommend.

Fish is always fresh and delicious. Service is friendly. Menu has not changed in years. Would be nice to see a few new dishes. Prices are really good.

Love the seafood selection and freshness. Great classic fish dishes with variety.

Stopped by for dinner not quite sure what to expect and it turned out to be a great meal. It started with a steaming bread dish then an outstanding salad. We shared the mussels marinara, very good. My wife had the shrimp fra diavolo and I had stuffed sole with crabmeat. We were both very satisfied. We will be back!

Excellent food,great atmosphere,good service.

This spot is worth trying. They have large portions for reasonable rates. Regularly well kept and with fantastic atmosphere. Highly recommended.

Giant HIT! Great place, what a hidden gem. FRESH, everything we ordered was fresh. Good size portions and fair pricing. This place is going on my "favorites list".

The best fresh seafood around

Great food, good price, good service. Although not a fancy place, it's definitely worth a visit.

Ordered take out. Food was very good. Looks like they have made the necessary accommodations to meet the pandemic obstacles. Still a keeper.

Had dinner there tonight. Food had nice flavor. Good presentation and quantity was good. Nice atmosphere too